package servertest_test import ( "os" "os/exec" "path/filepath" "strings" "testing" "github.com/juanfont/headscale/hscontrol/servertest" "github.com/stretchr/testify/require" ) // TestAPIv2OAuthScopes proves the v2 OAuth scope and tag enforcement through the // REAL Tailscale Terraform provider's client-credentials flow: the provider mints // a scoped access token at /api/v2/oauth/token, then runs one operation whose // allow/deny outcome must match the token's scope and tag grant. // // Each client is created with exactly the scopes/tags under test, and the // provider requests no scope narrowing, so the minted token carries the client's // full grant. The matrix covers right-scope-allowed, wrong-scope-denied, read vs // write, the "all" super-scope, and policy tag ownership (owned-by delegation). // // The oauth_keys rows drive the real provider's tailscale_oauth_client resource, // which omits the "capabilities" body field, so the request schema must make it // optional (it is). Drift is not asserted on the auth-key rows: the provider // defaults preauthorized=true on create but the server reads tagged keys back as // false, so a converged plan is never empty. That is orthogonal to scope // enforcement, so a clean apply is the allow proof. // // tofu is required, not optional: it ships in the nix dev shell, so a missing // binary means a broken environment and the test fails rather than skipping. func TestAPIv2OAuthScopes(t *testing.T) { srv := servertest.NewServer(t, servertest.WithRealListener()) owner := srv.CreateUser(t, "apiv2-oauth") creator := owner.ID // scopeMatrixPolicy declares every tag the matrix touches: tag:ci for the // auth-key rows, and the tag:k8s/tag:k8s-operator delegation for the // owned-by rows. setScopeMatrixPolicy(t, srv) // A registered node is the target for the device-scope rows. Its decimal id // is the device id the v2 API and the provider's device resources address. // A devices:core write token also grants devices:core:read, so whatever // get/post sequence the provider runs within the core family is satisfied; // the read-scope row then fails on the write, proving read vs write end to // end. devices:routes and feature_settings are proven exhaustively by the Go // matrix (apiv2_oauth_matrix_test.go), not here: the provider's routes // resource issues a cross-family device read a routes-only token would lack, // and the server's settings endpoint is read-only. deviceID := srv.CreateRegisteredNode(t, owner).StringID() deviceAuthorizeConfig := ` resource "tailscale_device_authorization" "d" { device_id = "` + deviceID + `" authorized = true } ` // The configs each exercise exactly one operation so a row's allow/deny // outcome is unambiguous. const ( authKeyConfig = ` resource "tailscale_tailnet_key" "k" { reusable = true ephemeral = false expiry = 3600 description = "oauth-scope-matrix" tags = ["tag:ci"] } ` aclConfig = ` resource "tailscale_acl" "policy" { acl = jsonencode({ tagOwners = { "tag:ci" = ["apiv2-oauth@"] "tag:k8s-operator" = [] "tag:k8s" = ["tag:k8s-operator"] "tag:other" = [] } acls = [{ action = "accept", src = ["*"], dst = ["*:*"] }] }) overwrite_existing_content = true } ` devicesReadConfig = ` data "tailscale_devices" "all" {} output "device_count" { value = length(data.tailscale_devices.all.devices) } ` // oauthClientConfig creates an OAuth client whose scope (oauth_keys:read) // is within an oauth_keys grant, so the only variable under test is whether // the caller may manage clients at all. oauthClientConfig = ` resource "tailscale_oauth_client" "c" { description = "oauth-scope-matrix-client" scopes = ["oauth_keys:read"] } ` // oauthClientEscalateConfig requests a scope (devices:core:read) that an // oauth_keys-only caller does not itself hold, so the escalation guard must // reject minting a broader client. oauthClientEscalateConfig = ` resource "tailscale_oauth_client" "c" { description = "oauth-scope-matrix-escalate" scopes = ["devices:core:read"] } ` ) // k8sAuthKeyConfig templates the auth-key tag for the owned-by rows. k8sAuthKeyConfig := func(tag string) string { return ` resource "tailscale_tailnet_key" "k" { reusable = true ephemeral = false expiry = 3600 description = "oauth-scope-matrix" tags = ["` + tag + `"] } ` } tests := []struct { name string // scopes/tags the OAuth client (and thus its minted token) holds. scopes []string tags []string // config is the single-operation HCL applied through the OAuth provider. config string // deny asserts apply fails; denyContains lists substrings, any of which // the failure output must contain. allow asserts a clean apply. deny bool denyContains []string }{ // auth_keys: write scope mints an auth key; read/wrong/all-read do not. { name: "auth_keys allows tailnet_key", scopes: []string{"auth_keys"}, tags: []string{"tag:ci"}, config: authKeyConfig, }, { name: "auth_keys:read denies tailnet_key", scopes: []string{"auth_keys:read"}, tags: []string{"tag:ci"}, config: authKeyConfig, deny: true, denyContains: []string{"403", "Forbidden", "missing the required scope"}, }, { name: "devices:core denies tailnet_key", scopes: []string{"devices:core"}, tags: []string{"tag:ci"}, config: authKeyConfig, deny: true, denyContains: []string{"403", "Forbidden", "missing the required scope"}, }, { name: "all allows tailnet_key", scopes: []string{"all"}, tags: []string{"tag:ci"}, config: authKeyConfig, }, { name: "all:read denies tailnet_key", scopes: []string{"all:read"}, tags: []string{"tag:ci"}, config: authKeyConfig, deny: true, denyContains: []string{"403", "Forbidden", "missing the required scope"}, }, // oauth_keys: managing OAuth clients. Read and wrong scopes are denied, and // a caller cannot mint a client carrying authority it lacks (escalation). { name: "oauth_keys allows oauth_client", scopes: []string{"oauth_keys"}, config: oauthClientConfig, }, { name: "oauth_keys:read denies oauth_client", scopes: []string{"oauth_keys:read"}, config: oauthClientConfig, deny: true, denyContains: []string{"403", "Forbidden", "missing the required scope"}, }, { name: "auth_keys denies oauth_client", scopes: []string{"auth_keys"}, tags: []string{"tag:ci"}, config: oauthClientConfig, deny: true, denyContains: []string{"403", "Forbidden", "missing the required scope"}, }, { name: "oauth_keys cannot escalate client scope", scopes: []string{"oauth_keys"}, config: oauthClientEscalateConfig, deny: true, denyContains: []string{"403", "Forbidden", "beyond the creating token"}, }, // policy_file: write scope sets the ACL; read does not. { name: "policy_file allows acl", scopes: []string{"policy_file"}, config: aclConfig, }, { name: "policy_file:read denies acl", scopes: []string{"policy_file:read"}, config: aclConfig, deny: true, denyContains: []string{"403", "Forbidden", "missing the required scope"}, }, // devices:core:read reads the devices data source. { name: "devices:core:read allows devices read", scopes: []string{"devices:core:read"}, config: devicesReadConfig, }, { name: "policy_file:read denies devices read", scopes: []string{"policy_file:read"}, config: devicesReadConfig, deny: true, denyContains: []string{"403", "Forbidden", "missing the required scope"}, }, // devices:core: a write-scoped token authorizes a device; the read scope // and a wrong-family scope are denied (read vs write through the real // provider's tailscale_device_authorization resource). { name: "devices:core allows device authorize", scopes: []string{"devices:core"}, tags: []string{"tag:ci"}, config: deviceAuthorizeConfig, }, { name: "devices:core:read denies device authorize", scopes: []string{"devices:core:read"}, config: deviceAuthorizeConfig, deny: true, denyContains: []string{"403", "Forbidden", "missing the required scope"}, }, { name: "policy_file denies device authorize", scopes: []string{"policy_file"}, config: deviceAuthorizeConfig, deny: true, denyContains: []string{"403", "Forbidden", "missing the required scope"}, }, // Tag owned-by: a tag:k8s-operator client may use its own tag and the // tag:k8s it owns, but not an unowned tag. { name: "owned-by exact tag allowed", scopes: []string{"auth_keys"}, tags: []string{"tag:k8s-operator"}, config: k8sAuthKeyConfig("tag:k8s-operator"), }, { name: "owned-by delegated tag allowed", scopes: []string{"auth_keys"}, tags: []string{"tag:k8s-operator"}, config: k8sAuthKeyConfig("tag:k8s"), }, { name: "owned-by unowned tag denied", scopes: []string{"auth_keys"}, tags: []string{"tag:k8s-operator"}, config: k8sAuthKeyConfig("tag:other"), deny: true, denyContains: []string{"403", "Forbidden", "is not owned"}, }, } for _, tt := range tests { t.Run(tt.name, func(t *testing.T) { secret, client, err := srv.State().CreateOAuthClient(tt.scopes, tt.tags, "scope-matrix", &creator) require.NoError(t, err) tf := newTofuOAuth(t, srv.URL, client.ClientID, secret, oauthHCL(tt.config)) tf.run("init", "-no-color", "-input=false") if tt.deny { tf.runExpectError(t, tt.denyContains...) return } tf.run("apply", "-auto-approve", "-no-color", "-input=false", "-parallelism=1") }) } } // setScopeMatrixPolicy installs the policy the scope matrix relies on: tag:ci for // the auth-key rows, and the tag:k8s-operator → tag:k8s delegation for the // owned-by rows. func setScopeMatrixPolicy(t *testing.T, srv *servertest.TestServer) { t.Helper() // tag:other exists but is owned by no one, so the owned-by denial row tests a // grant denial (403) rather than a tag-not-in-policy rejection (400). const policy = `{"tagOwners":{"tag:ci":["apiv2-oauth@"],"tag:k8s-operator":[],"tag:k8s":["tag:k8s-operator"],"tag:other":[]},"acls":[{"action":"accept","src":["*"],"dst":["*:*"]}]}` st := srv.State() _, err := st.SetPolicy([]byte(policy)) require.NoError(t, err) _, err = st.SetPolicyInDB(policy) require.NoError(t, err) _, err = st.ReloadPolicy() require.NoError(t, err) } // oauthHCL wraps a single-operation body with the provider block. The provider // authenticates via the OAuth env vars newTofuOAuth sets, so the block is empty. func oauthHCL(body string) string { return ` terraform { required_providers { tailscale = { source = "tailscale/tailscale" version = "~> 0.21" } } } provider "tailscale" {} ` + body } // newTofuOAuth is a newTofu variant whose provider authenticates with OAuth // client credentials instead of an API key: it sets TAILSCALE_OAUTH_CLIENT_ID / // TAILSCALE_OAUTH_CLIENT_SECRET (the env vars the tailscale/tailscale provider // honors), so the real provider runs the client-credentials grant against // baseURL/api/v2/oauth/token. The client id is embedded in the secret, so the // secret embeds the client id (the provider sends both; the server derives the // client from the secret alone). func newTofuOAuth(t *testing.T, baseURL, clientID, clientSecret, config string) *tofu { t.Helper() bin, err := exec.LookPath("tofu") require.NoErrorf(t, err, "tofu is required for TestAPIv2OAuthScopes (provided by the nix dev shell)") dir := t.TempDir() require.NoError(t, os.WriteFile(filepath.Join(dir, "main.tf"), []byte(config), 0o600)) require.NoError(t, os.MkdirAll(filepath.Join(dir, "plugin-cache"), 0o755)) env := append( os.Environ(), "TAILSCALE_BASE_URL="+baseURL, "TAILSCALE_OAUTH_CLIENT_ID="+clientID, "TAILSCALE_OAUTH_CLIENT_SECRET="+clientSecret, "TAILSCALE_TAILNET=-", // Keep provider plugins inside the temp dir so the run is self-contained. "TF_PLUGIN_CACHE_DIR="+filepath.Join(dir, "plugin-cache"), ) cmd := func(args ...string) *exec.Cmd { c := exec.CommandContext(t.Context(), bin, args...) c.Dir = dir c.Env = env return c } return &tofu{t: t, cmd: cmd} } // runExpectError runs apply expecting FAILURE, asserting the combined output // contains at least one of mustContain. This is the deny half of every matrix // row: a scoped token attempting an operation it lacks the scope (or tag) for. func (tf *tofu) runExpectError(t *testing.T, mustContain ...string) { t.Helper() out, err := tf.cmd("apply", "-auto-approve", "-no-color", "-input=false", "-parallelism=1").CombinedOutput() require.Errorf(t, err, "expected apply to fail, but it succeeded:\n%s", out) combined := string(out) for _, want := range mustContain { if strings.Contains(combined, want) { return } } t.Fatalf("apply failed but output contained none of %v:\n%s", mustContain, combined) }