policy/v2: label sshTests failures with the dst alias

The report goes back to the policy author: name src and dst as written,
one line per dst occurrence, and a dst with no node as not reached.

hscontrol/apiv2_compat_test.go

@@ -80,10 +80,8 @@ var apiv2CompatSkipReasons = map[string]string{
 	"oauth/K2/0/outcome": unknownKeyType,
 	"oauth/K5/0/status":  unknownKeyType,
 
-	"oauth/J3/1/hostnames": sshTestHostnames,
-	"oauth/J4/0/hostnames": sshTestHostnames,
-	"oauth/J3/1/detail":    refusalDetail,
-	"oauth/J4/0/detail":    refusalDetail,
+	"oauth/J3/1/detail": refusalDetail,
+	"oauth/J4/0/detail": refusalDetail,
 
 	"oauth/E2/0/status":   taggedAllClientAnyTag,
 	"oauth/E2/0/outcome":  taggedAllClientAnyTag,
@@ -229,7 +227,6 @@ const (
 	bodyBeforeScope        = "BODY_BEFORE_SCOPE: headscale validates a createKey body before the token's scope and answers 422; SaaS answers 404 for the missing scope"
 	taggedAllClientAnyTag  = "TAGGED_ALL_CLIENT_ANY_TAG: SaaS lets a tagged all-scope client's token ask only for the client's tags; headscale lets it ask for any tag"
 	retagRemovesUnownedTag = "RETAG_REMOVES_UNOWNED_TAG: SaaS refuses a token's retag of a device holding a tag outside the token's grant with 400 cannot remove current tags; headscale replaces the tags"
-	sshTestHostnames       = "SSH_TEST_HOSTNAMES: headscale names the nodes behind a failing sshTests destination; SaaS names the destination as written"
 )
 
 // Differences no planned change removes yet.

hscontrol/policy/v2/policytester_compat_test.go

@@ -53,8 +53,6 @@ var knownPolicyTesterDivergences = map[string]string{ //nolint:gosec // strings
 	"policytest-src-wildcard-deny/verdict":     testSrcShape,
 
 	"policytest-dst-multinode-partial-accept/verdict": "TEST_DST_EVERY_NODE: SaaS accepts only when every node of the dst alias is reached; headscale when one is",
-
-	"policytest-report-both-blocks/label": sshTestNodeLabel,
 }
 
 const (
@@ -179,8 +177,7 @@ var (
 // with the ones headscale's evaluators report, as sorted lines of
 // "src -> dst: want" (tests), "src/user: want @ dst" (sshTests) and
 // "src: error" for an entry that could not be evaluated. Repeats are kept.
-// An sshTests dst is the entry's alias in headscale's form: SaaS names the
-// alias, headscale the node, which the label check compares.
+// Both name an sshTests src and dst as written.
 func requireFailureBreakdown(
 	t *testing.T,
 	skips map[string]string,
@@ -203,14 +200,7 @@ func requireFailureBreakdown(
 			}
 
 			if m := saasSSHTestFailRE.FindStringSubmatch(line); m != nil {
-				dst := m[1]
-
-				alias, err := parseAlias(dst)
-				if err == nil {
-					dst = alias.String()
-				}
-
-				want = append(want, fmt.Sprintf("%s/%s: %s @ %s", d.User, m[2], m[3], dst))
+				want = append(want, fmt.Sprintf("%s/%s: %s @ %s", d.User, m[2], m[3], m[1]))
 
 				continue
 			}
@@ -306,14 +296,11 @@ func testerBreakdown(pm *PolicyManager) []string {
 
 	cache := make(map[types.NodeID]*tailcfg.SSHPolicy)
 
-	// One result per entry, in policy order.
-	for i, res := range runSSHPolicyTests(pm.pol, pm.users, pm.nodes, cache).Results {
+	for _, res := range runSSHPolicyTests(pm.pol, pm.users, pm.nodes, cache).Results {
 		for range res.Errors {
 			out = append(out, res.Src+": error")
 		}
 
-		aliases := sshTestDstAliases(pm, pm.pol.SSHTests[i])
-
 		for want, fails := range map[string]map[string][]string{
 			"accept": res.AcceptFail,
 			"deny":   res.DenyFail,
@@ -321,7 +308,7 @@ func testerBreakdown(pm *PolicyManager) []string {
 		} {
 			for user, dsts := range fails {
 				for _, dst := range dsts {
-					out = append(out, fmt.Sprintf("%s/%s: %s @ %s", res.Src, user, want, aliases[dst]))
+					out = append(out, fmt.Sprintf("%s/%s: %s @ %s", res.Src, user, want, dst))
 				}
 			}
 		}
@@ -332,30 +319,6 @@ func testerBreakdown(pm *PolicyManager) []string {
 	return out
 }
 
-// sshTestDstAliases maps each node hostname an sshTests entry reaches to the
-// first of its dst aliases that selects it, the one the evaluator checks the
-// node under.
-func sshTestDstAliases(pm *PolicyManager, test SSHPolicyTest) map[string]string {
-	_, srcUserID, _ := resolveSSHTestSource(test.Src, pm.pol, pm.users, pm.nodes)
-
-	out := make(map[string]string)
-
-	for _, alias := range test.Dst {
-		nodes, _, err := resolveSSHTestDestNodes(SSHTestDestinations{alias}, pm.pol, pm.users, pm.nodes, srcUserID)
-		if err != nil {
-			continue
-		}
-
-		for _, n := range nodes {
-			if _, ok := out[n.Hostname()]; !ok {
-				out[n.Hostname()] = alias.String()
-			}
-		}
-	}
-
-	return out
-}
-
 // nodeLabels lists the capture's hostnames that text names while the policy
 // does not, so they are there only because the report labels nodes.
 func nodeLabels(c *testcapture.Capture, text string) []string {

hscontrol/policy/v2/sshtest.go

@@ -34,6 +34,11 @@ type SSHPolicyTestResult struct {
 	DenyFail   map[string][]string `json:"deny_fail,omitempty"`
 	CheckOK    map[string][]string `json:"check_ok,omitempty"`
 	CheckFail  map[string][]string `json:"check_fail,omitempty"`
+
+	// CheckDenied holds the check failures where a node was not reached at
+	// all. A dst alias can cover nodes that fail in different ways, and one
+	// node not reached makes the alias DENIED.
+	CheckDenied map[string][]string `json:"check_denied,omitempty"`
 }
 
 // SSHPolicyTestResults aggregates one evaluation run.
@@ -82,7 +87,7 @@ func (r SSHPolicyTestResults) Errors() string {
 
 		for _, user := range sortedUsers(res.CheckFail) {
 			for _, dst := range res.CheckFail[user] {
-				// The reason scans AcceptOK; skip it for lines that
+				// The reason scans CheckDenied; skip it for lines that
 				// are only counted.
 				var reason string
 				if !failures.full() {
@@ -117,11 +122,11 @@ func displayUser(u string) string {
 // checkFailReason annotates a check-fail with whether the user reached
 // the dst via an accept rule or did not reach at all.
 func checkFailReason(res SSHPolicyTestResult, user, dst string) string {
-	if slices.Contains(res.AcceptOK[user], dst) {
-		return "ALLOWED via accept"
+	if slices.Contains(res.CheckDenied[user], dst) {
+		return "DENIED"
 	}
 
-	return "DENIED"
+	return "ALLOWED via accept"
 }
 
 // RunSSHTests evaluates the live policy's sshTests block and wraps any
@@ -193,7 +198,7 @@ func runSSHPolicyTest(
 ) SSHPolicyTestResult {
 	srcLabel := ""
 	if test.Src != nil {
-		srcLabel = test.Src.String()
+		srcLabel = sshTestLabel(test.Src)
 	}
 
 	res := SSHPolicyTestResult{
@@ -227,7 +232,7 @@ func runSSHPolicyTest(
 		return res
 	}
 
-	dstNodes, emptyDsts, err := resolveSSHTestDestNodes(test.Dst, pol, users, nodes, srcUserID)
+	dsts, err := resolveSSHTestDests(test.Dst, pol, users, nodes, srcUserID)
 	if err != nil {
 		res.Passed = false
 		res.Errors = append(res.Errors,
@@ -236,17 +241,6 @@ func runSSHPolicyTest(
 		return res
 	}
 
-	// A dst resolving to zero nodes would silently pass.
-	for _, dst := range emptyDsts {
-		res.Passed = false
-		res.Errors = append(res.Errors,
-			fmt.Sprintf("dst alias %q resolved to no nodes", dst))
-	}
-
-	if len(dstNodes) == 0 {
-		return res
-	}
-
 	for _, g := range []struct {
 		users []SSHUser
 		kind  sshAssertion
@@ -258,7 +252,7 @@ func runSSHPolicyTest(
 		for _, user := range g.users {
 			evaluateAssertion(
 				pol, users, nodes, cache,
-				srcAddrs, dstNodes, user.String(),
+				srcAddrs, dsts, user.String(),
 				g.kind, &res,
 			)
 		}
@@ -275,10 +269,77 @@ const (
 	assertCheck
 )
 
-// evaluateAssertion walks every (srcAddr, dstNode) pair for one user
-// and records the outcome. Empty username fails — SSH login users
-// cannot be empty even when parse accepted it.
+// evaluateAssertion records one user's outcome for each dst alias of an
+// entry, under the alias as written: the report goes back to the policy
+// author, who may not be allowed to list nodes. An alias passes when every
+// node it selects does, for every src address; one selecting no node is not
+// reached. Each distinct alias is evaluated once and reported at every
+// occurrence, as Tailscale SaaS reports them.
 func evaluateAssertion(
+	pol *Policy,
+	users []types.User,
+	nodes views.Slice[types.NodeView],
+	cache map[types.NodeID]*tailcfg.SSHPolicy,
+	srcAddrs []netip.Addr,
+	dsts []sshTestDst,
+	user string,
+	kind sshAssertion,
+	res *SSHPolicyTestResult,
+) {
+	type outcome struct{ passed, notReached, failed bool }
+
+	seen := make(map[string]outcome, len(dsts))
+
+	for _, dst := range dsts {
+		o, ok := seen[dst.label]
+		if !ok {
+			passed, notReached, err := sshTestAliasOutcome(
+				pol, users, nodes, cache, srcAddrs, dst.nodes, user, kind,
+			)
+			if err != nil {
+				res.Passed = false
+				res.Errors = append(res.Errors,
+					fmt.Sprintf("compiling SSH policy for %s: %v", dst.label, err))
+			}
+
+			o = outcome{passed, notReached, err != nil}
+			seen[dst.label] = o
+		}
+
+		if o.failed {
+			continue
+		}
+
+		if !o.passed {
+			res.Passed = false
+		}
+
+		switch {
+		case kind == assertAccept && o.passed:
+			res.AcceptOK = appendUserDst(res.AcceptOK, user, dst.label)
+		case kind == assertAccept:
+			res.AcceptFail = appendUserDst(res.AcceptFail, user, dst.label)
+		case kind == assertDeny && o.passed:
+			res.DenyOK = appendUserDst(res.DenyOK, user, dst.label)
+		case kind == assertDeny:
+			res.DenyFail = appendUserDst(res.DenyFail, user, dst.label)
+		case o.passed:
+			res.CheckOK = appendUserDst(res.CheckOK, user, dst.label)
+		default:
+			res.CheckFail = appendUserDst(res.CheckFail, user, dst.label)
+
+			if o.notReached {
+				res.CheckDenied = appendUserDst(res.CheckDenied, user, dst.label)
+			}
+		}
+	}
+}
+
+// sshTestAliasOutcome reports whether user's assertion holds on every node
+// of one dst alias from every src address, and whether a failing node was
+// not reached at all. All src addresses must agree: the first
+// counter-example fails the node.
+func sshTestAliasOutcome(
 	pol *Policy,
 	users []types.User,
 	nodes views.Slice[types.NodeView],
@@ -287,82 +348,43 @@ func evaluateAssertion(
 	dstNodes []types.NodeView,
 	user string,
 	kind sshAssertion,
-	res *SSHPolicyTestResult,
-) {
-dstLoop:
+) (bool, bool, error) {
+	if len(dstNodes) == 0 {
+		return kind == assertDeny, true, nil
+	}
+
+	passed, notReached := true, false
+
 	for _, dst := range dstNodes {
 		dstPol, err := compiledSSHPolicy(pol, users, nodes, cache, dst)
 		if err != nil {
-			res.Passed = false
-			res.Errors = append(res.Errors,
-				fmt.Sprintf("compiling SSH policy for %s: %v",
-					dst.Hostname(), err))
-
-			continue
+			return false, false, err
 		}
 
-		dstLabel := dst.Hostname()
-
-		acceptHit := false
-		checkHit := false
-
 		for _, srcAddr := range srcAddrs {
 			a, c := reachability(dstPol, srcAddr, user)
-			if a {
-				acceptHit = true
-			}
 
-			if c {
-				checkHit = true
-			}
+			var holds bool
 
-			// All src IPs must agree; one counter-example fails
-			// the whole (user, dst) pair.
 			switch kind {
 			case assertAccept:
-				if !a {
-					res.Passed = false
-					res.AcceptFail = appendUserDst(res.AcceptFail, user, dstLabel)
-
-					continue dstLoop
-				}
+				holds = a
 			case assertDeny:
-				if a {
-					res.Passed = false
-					res.DenyFail = appendUserDst(res.DenyFail, user, dstLabel)
-
-					continue dstLoop
-				}
+				holds = !a
 			case assertCheck:
-				if !c {
-					res.Passed = false
-					res.CheckFail = appendUserDst(res.CheckFail, user, dstLabel)
-
-					// Record whether the accept side passed so
-					// the rendered error can say "ALLOWED via
-					// accept" instead of "DENIED".
-					if a {
-						res.AcceptOK = appendUserDst(res.AcceptOK, user, dstLabel)
-					}
-
-					continue dstLoop
-				}
+				holds = c
 			}
-		}
 
-		switch kind {
-		case assertAccept:
-			if acceptHit {
-				res.AcceptOK = appendUserDst(res.AcceptOK, user, dstLabel)
-			}
-		case assertDeny:
-			res.DenyOK = appendUserDst(res.DenyOK, user, dstLabel)
-		case assertCheck:
-			if checkHit {
-				res.CheckOK = appendUserDst(res.CheckOK, user, dstLabel)
+			if !holds {
+				passed = false
+				notReached = notReached || !a
+
+				break
 			}
 		}
 	}
+
+	return passed, notReached, nil
 }
 
 // appendUserDst appends dst to m[user], allocating m on first use.
@@ -456,105 +478,107 @@ func resolveSSHTestSource(
 	return out, userID, nil
 }
 
-// resolveSSHTestDestNodes maps each dst alias to its destination
-// [types.NodeView]s. autogroup:self needs special handling: it cannot
-// resolve without per-node context, so it walks the node set keyed on
-// src's owning user. Other aliases resolve to an [netipx.IPSet] and match
-// via [types.NodeView.InIPSet].
-func resolveSSHTestDestNodes(
+// sshTestLabel names an sshTests alias as its author writes it: a single
+// address bare, not as a /32 or /128 prefix.
+func sshTestLabel(alias Alias) string {
+	if p, ok := alias.(*Prefix); ok {
+		return filterIP(netip.Prefix(*p))
+	}
+
+	return alias.String()
+}
+
+// sshTestDst is one dst alias of an sshTests entry and the nodes it
+// selects.
+type sshTestDst struct {
+	label string
+	nodes []types.NodeView
+}
+
+// resolveSSHTestDests resolves each dst alias of an entry, in order and
+// once per occurrence, so the report can name every alias as written.
+// Each distinct alias resolves once.
+func resolveSSHTestDests(
 	dsts SSHTestDestinations,
 	pol *Policy,
 	users []types.User,
 	nodes views.Slice[types.NodeView],
 	srcUserID uint,
-) ([]types.NodeView, []string, error) {
-	seen := make(map[types.NodeID]struct{})
-
-	var (
-		out       []types.NodeView
-		emptyDsts []string
-	)
+) ([]sshTestDst, error) {
+	selected := make(map[string][]types.NodeView, len(dsts))
+	out := make([]sshTestDst, 0, len(dsts))
 
 	for _, alias := range dsts {
-		dstLabel := alias.String()
-		matched := false
+		label := sshTestLabel(alias)
 
-		if ag, ok := alias.(*AutoGroup); ok && ag.Is(AutoGroupSelf) {
-			// autogroup:self resolves to non-tagged nodes owned by
-			// the same user as src; tagged/IP sources have no user.
-			if srcUserID == 0 {
-				emptyDsts = append(emptyDsts, dstLabel)
+		dstNodes, ok := selected[label]
+		if !ok {
+			var err error
 
-				continue
+			dstNodes, err = sshTestDstNodes(alias, pol, users, nodes, srcUserID)
+			if err != nil {
+				return nil, err
 			}
 
-			for _, n := range nodes.All() {
-				if n.IsTagged() {
-					continue
-				}
-
-				if !n.User().Valid() {
-					continue
-				}
-
-				if n.User().ID() != srcUserID {
-					continue
-				}
-
-				matched = true
-
-				if _, dup := seen[n.ID()]; dup {
-					continue
-				}
-
-				seen[n.ID()] = struct{}{}
-				out = append(out, n)
-			}
-
-			if !matched {
-				emptyDsts = append(emptyDsts, dstLabel)
-			}
-
-			continue
+			selected[label] = dstNodes
 		}
 
-		ips, err := alias.Resolve(pol, users, nodes)
-		if err != nil {
-			return nil, nil, fmt.Errorf("resolving destination %q: %w", dstLabel, err)
-		}
+		out = append(out, sshTestDst{label: label, nodes: dstNodes})
+	}
 
-		if ips == nil || ips.Empty() {
-			emptyDsts = append(emptyDsts, dstLabel)
+	return out, nil
+}
 
-			continue
-		}
+// sshTestDstNodes returns the nodes one dst alias selects. autogroup:self
+// cannot resolve without per-node context, so it walks the node set keyed
+// on src's owning user. Other aliases resolve to an [netipx.IPSet] and
+// match via [types.NodeView.InIPSet].
+func sshTestDstNodes(
+	alias Alias,
+	pol *Policy,
+	users []types.User,
+	nodes views.Slice[types.NodeView],
+	srcUserID uint,
+) ([]types.NodeView, error) {
+	var out []types.NodeView
 
-		set, err := prefixesToIPSet(ips.Prefixes())
-		if err != nil {
-			return nil, nil, fmt.Errorf("building IPSet for %q: %w", dstLabel, err)
+	if ag, ok := alias.(*AutoGroup); ok && ag.Is(AutoGroupSelf) {
+		// autogroup:self is the src user's untagged nodes; tagged and
+		// address sources have no user.
+		if srcUserID == 0 {
+			return nil, nil
 		}
 
 		for _, n := range nodes.All() {
-			if !n.InIPSet(set) {
-				continue
+			if !n.IsTagged() && n.User().Valid() && n.User().ID() == srcUserID {
+				out = append(out, n)
 			}
-
-			matched = true
-
-			if _, dup := seen[n.ID()]; dup {
-				continue
-			}
-
-			seen[n.ID()] = struct{}{}
-			out = append(out, n)
 		}
 
-		if !matched {
-			emptyDsts = append(emptyDsts, dstLabel)
+		return out, nil
+	}
+
+	ips, err := alias.Resolve(pol, users, nodes)
+	if err != nil {
+		return nil, fmt.Errorf("resolving destination %q: %w", sshTestLabel(alias), err)
+	}
+
+	if ips == nil || ips.Empty() {
+		return nil, nil
+	}
+
+	set, err := prefixesToIPSet(ips.Prefixes())
+	if err != nil {
+		return nil, fmt.Errorf("building IPSet for %q: %w", sshTestLabel(alias), err)
+	}
+
+	for _, n := range nodes.All() {
+		if n.InIPSet(set) {
+			out = append(out, n)
 		}
 	}
 
-	return out, emptyDsts, nil
+	return out, nil
 }
 
 // prefixesToIPSet builds the [netipx.IPSet] that [types.NodeView.InIPSet]

hscontrol/policy/v2/sshtest_test.go

@@ -715,11 +715,9 @@ func TestRunSSHTests(t *testing.T) {
 			wantErrSub: []string{"alice@headscale.net", "expected ALLOWED"},
 		},
 		{
-			// tag:empty has an owner but no tagged nodes, so the dst
-			// alias resolves to no nodes. Without the empty-dst guard
-			// the per-assertion loop runs zero iterations and the
-			// test silently passes — exactly the regression the
-			// guard exists to catch.
+			// tag:empty has an owner but no tagged nodes: an alias
+			// selecting no node is not reached, so the accept fails
+			// instead of passing over zero nodes.
 			name: "dst-tag-with-no-tagged-nodes-fails",
 			policy: `{
 				"tagOwners": { "tag:empty": ["alice@headscale.net"] },
@@ -730,12 +728,11 @@ func TestRunSSHTests(t *testing.T) {
 				}]
 			}`,
 			wantPass:   false,
-			wantErrSub: []string{"tag:empty", "resolved to no nodes"},
+			wantErrSub: []string{"-> tag:empty: expected ALLOWED, got DENIED"},
 		},
 		{
 			// autogroup:self from a tag src has no user identity to
-			// scope to, so the dst alias resolves to no nodes. Same
-			// empty-dst guard, distinct trigger path.
+			// scope to, so the dst alias selects no node either.
 			name: "dst-autogroup-self-from-tag-src-fails",
 			policy: `{
 				"tagOwners": { "tag:prod": ["alice@headscale.net"] },
@@ -746,7 +743,7 @@ func TestRunSSHTests(t *testing.T) {
 				}]
 			}`,
 			wantPass:   false,
-			wantErrSub: []string{"autogroup:self", "resolved to no nodes"},
+			wantErrSub: []string{"-> autogroup:self: expected ALLOWED, got DENIED"},
 		},
 		{
 			name: "src-address-space-deny-pass",
@@ -1066,22 +1063,22 @@ func TestSSHPolicyTestResultsErrorsRendering(t *testing.T) {
 			{
 				Src: "alice@headscale.net",
 				AcceptFail: map[string][]string{
-					"root": {"server"},
+					"root": {"tag:server"},
 				},
 			},
 			{
 				Src: "bob@headscale.net",
 				DenyFail: map[string][]string{
-					"root": {"alice-laptop"},
+					"root": {"group:people"},
 				},
 			},
 			{
 				Src: "alice@headscale.net",
 				CheckFail: map[string][]string{
-					"ubuntu": {"server"},
+					"ubuntu": {"tag:server", "tag:prod"},
 				},
-				AcceptOK: map[string][]string{
-					"ubuntu": {"server"},
+				CheckDenied: map[string][]string{
+					"ubuntu": {"tag:prod"},
 				},
 			},
 		},
@@ -1089,13 +1086,66 @@ func TestSSHPolicyTestResultsErrorsRendering(t *testing.T) {
 
 	rendered := results.Errors()
 	for _, sub := range []string{
-		"alice@headscale.net/root -> server: expected ALLOWED, got DENIED",
-		"bob@headscale.net/root -> alice-laptop: expected DENIED, got ALLOWED",
-		"alice@headscale.net/ubuntu -> server: expected ALLOWED via check, got ALLOWED via accept",
+		"alice@headscale.net/root -> tag:server: expected ALLOWED, got DENIED",
+		"bob@headscale.net/root -> group:people: expected DENIED, got ALLOWED",
+		"alice@headscale.net/ubuntu -> tag:server: expected ALLOWED via check, got ALLOWED via accept",
+		"alice@headscale.net/ubuntu -> tag:prod: expected ALLOWED via check, got DENIED",
 	} {
 		assert.Contains(t, rendered, sub)
 	}
 
-	assert.Equal(t, 3, strings.Count(rendered, "\n")+1,
+	assert.Equal(t, 4, strings.Count(rendered, "\n")+1,
 		"expected one line per failing assertion")
 }
+
+// TestSSHTestsReportNamesAliasNotNode: the report goes back to the policy
+// author, who may not be allowed to list nodes, so src and dst are named as
+// written, one line per dst occurrence, as Tailscale SaaS reports them.
+func TestSSHTestsReportNamesAliasNotNode(t *testing.T) {
+	users := sshTestUsers()
+	nodes := sshTestNodes(users)
+
+	pm, err := NewPolicyManager([]byte(`{}`), users, nodes.ViewSlice())
+	require.NoError(t, err)
+
+	// group:people covers alice's nodes, which her own rule reaches by
+	// accept, and bob's and thor's, not reached at all: it is DENIED.
+	const policy = `{
+		"groups": {"group:people": ["alice@headscale.net", "bob@headscale.net", "thor@example.org"]},
+		"tagOwners": {"tag:server": ["alice@headscale.net"], "tag:empty": ["alice@headscale.net"]},
+		"ssh": [{
+			"action": "accept",
+			"src":    ["autogroup:member"],
+			"dst":    ["autogroup:self"],
+			"users":  ["root"]
+		}],
+		"sshTests": [
+			{
+				"src":    "10.0.0.1",
+				"dst":    ["100.64.0.3", "tag:server", "tag:server", "tag:empty"],
+				"accept": ["root"]
+			},
+			{"src": "alice@headscale.net", "dst": ["autogroup:self"], "deny": ["root"]},
+			{"src": "alice@headscale.net", "dst": ["group:people"], "check": ["root"]}
+		]
+	}`
+
+	_, err = pm.SetPolicy([]byte(policy))
+	require.ErrorIs(t, err, errSSHPolicyTestsFailed)
+
+	for line, want := range map[string]int{
+		"10.0.0.1/root -> 100.64.0.3: expected ALLOWED, got DENIED":                        1,
+		"10.0.0.1/root -> tag:server: expected ALLOWED, got DENIED":                        2,
+		"10.0.0.1/root -> tag:empty: expected ALLOWED, got DENIED":                         1,
+		"alice@headscale.net/root -> autogroup:self: expected DENIED, got ALLOWED":         1,
+		"alice@headscale.net/root -> group:people: expected ALLOWED via check, got DENIED": 1,
+	} {
+		assert.Equal(t, want, strings.Count(err.Error(), line), line)
+	}
+
+	for _, node := range nodes {
+		if !strings.Contains(policy, node.Hostname) {
+			assert.NotContains(t, err.Error(), node.Hostname)
+		}
+	}
+}

hscontrol/policy/v2/sshtester_compat_test.go

@@ -14,33 +14,7 @@ import (
 
 // knownSSHTesterDivergences names the engine gap for each check where
 // headscale and upstream disagree, keyed <test_id>/<check>.
-var knownSSHTesterDivergences = map[string]string{
-	"sshtest-accept-fail-no-ssh-rule/label":            sshTestNodeLabel,
-	"sshtest-accept-fail-wrong-login-user/label":       sshTestNodeLabel,
-	"sshtest-both-tests-pass-sshTests-fail/label":      sshTestNodeLabel,
-	"sshtest-deny-fail-policy-allows/label":            sshTestNodeLabel,
-	"sshtest-malformed-empty-user/label":               sshTestNodeLabel,
-	"sshtest-mixed-acls-tcp22-allow-no-ssh-rule/label": sshTestNodeLabel,
-	"sshtest-user-localpart-domain-mismatch/label":     sshTestNodeLabel,
-	"sshtest-user-nonroot-blocks-root/label":           sshTestNodeLabel,
-	"sshtest-fail-label-host-alias/label":              sshTestNodeLabel,
-	"sshtest-fail-label-ip-dst/label":                  sshTestNodeLabel,
-	"sshtest-fail-label-same-node-twice/label":         sshTestNodeLabel,
-	"sshtest-fail-label-user-dst/label":                sshTestNodeLabel,
-	"sshtest-repeated-names/label":                     sshTestNodeLabel,
-	"sshtest-report-multi/label":                       sshTestNodeLabel,
-	"sshtest-src-unassigned-ip-accept/label":           sshTestNodeLabel,
-
-	"sshtest-fail-label-same-node-twice/breakdown": "SSHTEST_PER_ALIAS: SaaS reports each dst alias, also two naming one node; headscale checks each node once",
-	"sshtest-fail-label-ip-no-device/breakdown":    sshTestNoDevice,
-	"sshtest-report-multi/breakdown":               "SSHTEST_PER_ALIAS+SSHTEST_NO_DEVICE: SaaS reports one line per dst alias and a deviceless alias as not reached; headscale one per node and an error",
-	"sshtest-src-unassigned-ip-accept/breakdown":   "SSHTEST_SRC_LABEL: SaaS labels a single-address source as written, headscale as a /32 prefix",
-}
-
-const (
-	sshTestNodeLabel = "SSHTEST_NODE_LABEL: headscale names each failing dst node by hostname; SaaS names the dst as written"
-	sshTestNoDevice  = "SSHTEST_NO_DEVICE: SaaS reports a dst that selects no device as not reached; headscale as an error"
-)
+var knownSSHTesterDivergences = map[string]string{}
 
 func TestSSHTesterCompat(t *testing.T) {
 	t.Parallel()

hscontrol/policy/v2/test_test.go

@@ -468,7 +468,7 @@ func TestFailureBreakdownIsBounded(t *testing.T) {
 		{
 			name: "sshTests dst without node",
 			block: `"sshTests": [{"src": "` + name + `", "dst": [` +
-				strings.Repeat(`"gone",`, failures) + `], "deny": ["root"]}]`,
+				strings.Repeat(`"gone",`, failures) + `], "accept": ["root"]}]`,
 			sentinel: errSSHPolicyTestsFailed,
 		},
 		{